"From my brief interactions with you—even your emails—you come across as very assertive. Like 99th percentile assertive.”
This was feedback given to me by a pastor of over 40 years who just started coaching me. We’ve never met in person and have probably emailed a dozen times, sent a few texts, and had 3-4 hours of Zoom calls. That’s it, but he already had a read on me. We were debriefing the recent staff retreat I was on.
I personally don’t view myself as “very assertive.” I might choose “mildly assertive” or “sometimes assertive,” but “very” feels extra strong. Maybe I get diagnosed as “very” because I prefer texting over talking and don’t use exclamation points, which can come across as cold and heartless.
Since January, I’ve been a part of executing six full-day onsite meetings, two half-day meetings (one on a Wednesday morning in Texas and the second the next morning in Costa Rica—which was a choice), and two retreats for our church leadership.
Half-days and full-days move quickly. Once they’re done you go home. Retreats have been a different animal. We’re staying away from the office and our downtime plus all meals are shared. For these, I’m simultaneously helping to facilitate them and I’m a member of the team serving as an active participant. So, with the additional time we spend together combined with our years of familiarity, I anticipate that at some point the conversation will get uncomfortable.
I’ve never been disappointed.

I’m not a conflict nor a crisis junkie, but I also don’t get bothered when things turn uncomfortable. I know good conflict provides the path to a stronger team. Thus, when our last retreat resulted in a period of “I’m finding myself frustrated with this conversation,” I stayed there. (I also was a large portion of the reason it was getting frustrating.) While not a meeting sadist, I will poke and prod and look for areas to challenge. Further, my pain tolerance for discomfort is quite high—saying the quiet part out loud is normal. (Maybe that’s a contributing factor to the “very assertive” comment, but I digress.)
So, in debriefing the retreat with Larry (that’s his name), I wanted to understand where I went wrong. He sat in his chair 1,500 miles away, giving thoughts he’s probably given 1,500 times before—but he gave them as if they were just for me. Let’s put the feedback in its fuller context.
From my brief interactions with you—even your emails—you come across as very assertive. Like 99th percentile assertive. Even on these calls your voice is loud. And we might not say it out loud but we tend to think that everyone is like us or will be when they grow up.
I guess Larry says the quiet part out loud, too.
Most of us want people to be more like us.
“Okay, I get it. But isn’t it better if we can just fight and argue and come to conclusions like that?” I wasn’t in full-on disagreement but it felt like less conflict was also less good.
“Yeah, it probably is. But it won’t happen like that. And as your team grows, you’ll always have to adjust. You don’t know what baggage people are bringing, or their histories, or their father wounds, or anything else. You could have fully lived my entire life and had a completely different interpretation of it.”
“I understand what you’re saying, but I simultaneously hate it.”

We do what we do because we believe it is best. Most of us don’t go through life thinking, “You know what? I am fully committed to having the sixth-best ideas.” Tested or untested, the way we respond to people, the way we act in a meeting, and the way we interpret what “best” is often comes right out of our own experiences, culture, family of origin, and feelings of propriety. If it worked for me, it’ll work for thee.
And then, without thinking, our own scripts become the measuring rod for others. Once they “get it,” they’ll come over to our side. It’s only a matter of time.
Think about the last time you gave feedback. If you had to guess, what percentage of that feedback was based on measuring that person against what you do? You weren’t just sitting there as a blank slate—offering a response out in a vacuum. It was based in something you believed was right—and likely something you do. How many extroverts have told the introvert some version of “be more outgoing”? And how many introverts have told extroverts some version of “maybe be quieter”? But such feedback gets tiring because what makes one approach better than another?
How do we adjust the reflex to make someone be more like us? I’ll give one perspective and one action.
It starts with having the humility to realize that people don’t need to be more like us. They’re on a different path and the destination isn’t to look like you—it’s to be who God has made them to be.
And how can you be specific about this in the moment when you’re trying to give the feedback? Get suspicious about your first response. Take a beat (even ten seconds) and ask, “What do they need to hear right now?” not “What do I want them to hear?”
Those ten seconds might be the difference between “helping” someone be more like you and truly helping them.
Thanks, Larry.

Do you resonate with the lesson? Do you realize that maybe—just maybe—you want people to be more like you when they grow up? If so, consider sharing the post.




Ouch! The truth stings! I wish there was a manual for this 😁 Thank you for providing the weekly brain food!